Elite Lawyers
Lawyers of Distinction
Avvo Rating 10.0
The State Bar of California
NYSBA Badge
Santa Clara County Bar Association
U.S Departament of Homeland Security
U.S Court of Appeals
United States Patent and Trademark
Association of American Trial Lawyers
Elite Lawyers Business James Cai 2017

Do Sports Clips Fall Under Fair use? The Jury is Still out

As social media continues to grow in popularity, the more it becomes ingrained into our daily lives. For many people, social media has replaced face-to-face interactions with people and for some, it even replaces watching the news.

But because of social media’s immediate access to content, social media companies – and sometimes even their users – find themselves walking into a legal gray area, especially in regards to intellectual property rights. It’s an issue that some of our California readers may be following, as it has cropped up in the news in recent months because of issues concerning NFL sports clips.

Though the NFL has been taking aggressive legal actions to prevent copyright infringement and protect its intellectual property rights over exclusive programming and sports clips, some believe users and social media companies may have the right to fair use. If this is the case, then the NFL would need to be more cautious about sending out cease and desist letters and takedown notices in the future.

As you may already know, fair use is a legal doctrine used in copyright law that protects an individual or group of people from legal action for using a protected work without the owner’s permission, provided the work falls under the specific terms of fair use. In the case of sports clips, one might argue that posting the clips may be done for journalist purposes or to comment on them, which are both reasons allowed under the terms of fair use.

Though the U.S. Court of Appeals recently ruled that companies “must consider the existence of fair use before sending a takedown notification,” addressing whether something should be considered protected under fair use or not does still need to be addressed on a case by case basis. It’s for this reason that the jury is still out on whether sports clips should fall under the terms of fair use at this time.

Client Reviews
★★★★★
Mr. Cai Is a Diligent Attorney. My sister and I were defendants in a civil litigation case. We hired James Cai and his law firm, SAC Attorneys LLP. Mr. Cai is a diligent attorney and responded to our questions in a timely fashion. He and his staff were very helpful in keeping us informed of the proceedings of the case and in explaining each step. Mr. Cai is also very conscientious of fees and costs, and avoided unnecessary charges. The results of the Summary Adjudication sided with us. The Court Trial resulted in the “Final Statement of Decision” and “Judgment after Court Trial” overwhelmingly siding with us. Cynthia F.
★★★★★
I Am Truly Impressed. After spending a significant amount of time, money and efforts with my previous counsel at a larger law firm without getting meaningful results, I transferred my employment matter to SAC Attorneys LLP. The attorneys there were able to understand the complex situations of my case and put together an aggressive litigation strategy. We were able to file a compelling complaint within a week and forced the opposing party, which was represented by one of the largest law firms in California, to make a substantial settlement offer shortly thereafter. I am truly impressed by the no nonsense and results oriented approach by SAC Attorneys LLP attorneys. A job well done! X. Gao
★★★★★
They Took Time to Understand Our Technology. I am the founder of a bioinformatics start-up in the Silicon Valley and chose SAC Attorneys LLP as our corporate counsels. Their attorneys have great experience with high tech start-ups and were able to offer a highly competitive service plan while not sacrificing a bit of their quality of services. They took time to understand our technology and provided value added services by introducing investors and job candidates to us. We regard our attorneys at SAC Attorneys LLP not only as our legal advisors but also our venture partners. Dr. Pete S.